Report says democracies enable despots
Posted on Thu, Jan. 31, 2008
By WILLIAM C. MANN
Associated Press Writer
Authoritarian rulers are violating human rights around the world and
getting away with it largely because the U.S., European and other
established democracies accept their claims that holding elections makes
them democratic, Human Rights Watch said in its annual report Thursday.
By failing to demand that offenders honor their citizens' civil and
political rights and other requirements of true democracy, Western
democracies risk undermining human rights everywhere, the international
rights watchdog said.
Still, Kenneth Roth, Human Rights Watch's executive director, wrote in a
segment of the report called "Despots Masquerading as Democrats": "It is
a sign of hope that even dictators have come to believe that the route
to legitimacy runs by way of democratic credentials."
Among countries named as major violators of their democratic credentials
in 2007 were Kenya, Pakistan, Bahrain, Jordan, Nigeria, Russia and
Thailand. The report covered the year through November. In December,
Thailand's military government allowed elections and was voted out of
power by a large majority to end 16 months of rule by the junta.
The annual report is the 18th compiled by Human Rights Watch. It
summarizes human rights shortcomings in more than 75 countries.
Among other countries listed as abusers were Chad, Colombia, Congo,
Ethiopia, Eritrea, Libya, Iran, North Korea, Saudi Arabia and Vietnam.
It spoke of abuses by the United States, France and Britain, along with
Pakistan, in the name of a "war on terror."
German Chancellor Angela Merkel, French President Nicolas Sarkozy and
other European leaders were criticized for their reluctance to allow
Turkey to join the European Union, despite its improved human rights record.
The report said the EU "lost leverage itself and diminished the clout of
those in Turkey who have cited the prospect of EU membership as a reason
The report's emphasis, however, was the false democracies and the
countries that enable them.
"It's now too easy for autocrats to get away with mounting a sham
democracy," Roth said in a statement. "That's because too many Western
governments insist on elections and leave it at that."
Ignored are "the key human rights issues that make democracy function: a
free press, peaceful assembly and a functioning civil society that can
really challenge power," he said.
The report said elections were manipulated in a number of ways, including:
-Fraud: Chad, Jordan, Kazakhstan, Nigeria, Uzbekistan.
-Control of electoral machinery: Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Malaysia,
-Interfering with opposition candidates: Belarus, Cuba, Egypt, Iran,
Israel in the occupied Palestinian territories, Libya, Turkmenistan, Uganda.
-Political violence: Cambodia, Congo, Ethiopia, Lebanon.
-Stifling the media and civil society: Russia, Tunisia.
-Undermining the law: China, Pakistan.
Both domestic and international law forbid most of these tactics, Human
Rights Watch said.
In the face of this, Human Rights Watch said, "The United States and the
European Union should ... demand they uphold rights guaranteed by
international law, including a free media, freedom of assembly and a
"It seems Washington and European governments will accept even the most
dubious election so long as the 'victor' is a strategic or commercial
ally," Roth said.
State Department spokesman Sean McCormack said Wednesday he had not seen
the report and could not comment on it. He said, however, "In terms of
the United States and this administration speaking up in defense of, and
advocating for, and putting its effort behind its rhetoric, I don't
think there's any question about where we stand in terms of promotion of
The report said some of the Western countries, including the United
States, have made it difficult to demand that offending governments
honor human rights by committing abuses themselves in campaigning
Also, "they will devalue the currency of democracy" if they allow the
need for resources, trade and security to make despotism acceptable, and
the despots will have "a powerful tool for deflecting pressure to uphold
"It is time to stop selling democracy on the cheap."