Calls to clarify Lord Ashcroft's position after revelation that he
provided flights for William Hague's visit to Havana last year, and then
accompanied him to top-level meetings
It was a scene that Graham Greene would surely have enjoyed: our men in
Havana, a billionaire peer and a top Tory politician, sipping drinks on
a 150ft yacht in the Hemingway marina before holding talks with a
But the decision of William Hague to allow Lord Ashcroft to provide
flights for and then accompany him on an official foreign visit to Cuba
has prompted calls for the Tories to clarify the role of the party's
biggest-ever donor, whose donations are still subject to an official
investigation. The disclosure raises new questions about Ashcroft's role
and his close relationship with Hague. It follows previous disclosures
in the Observer that Ashcroft accompanied Hague to key meetings in
Washington in November.
Last night Labour and the Lib Dems expressed surprise that Ashcroft, who
has extensive business interests in the surrounding Caribbean and no
official frontbench role in the party, is now Hague's right-hand man,
attending meetings with foreign powerbrokers as the Tories prepare for
Last night Chris Bryant, a Foreign Office minister, questioned the
Tories' decision to meet only Cuban government officials, a move he said
breached the spirit of European rules, which state that such visits
should not take place until and unless until there is a freedom to meet
opponents of the regime.
Chris Bryant, the minister for Europe, said Hague's meeting with
official government figures was a "slap in the face" for opponents of
the regime. "It seems William Hague held talks with the Cuban government
but completely ignored the opposition in Cuba. It has been an accepted
principle across Europe, enshrined in the EU common position, that we
would only make high-level visits to Cuba if we were free to visit
whomever we want. Hague's actions have been a real slap in the face for
those who are campaigning for a more open Cuba.
"Every time he is asked, Hague is remarkably vague about Lord Ashcroft's
tax status. Yet he seems to have not just used his plane, but travelled
with him on countless occasions and stayed on his luxury yacht. What on
earth is Ashcroft doing attending Hague's overseas meetings with foreign
Lord Oakeshott, the Lib Dem Treasury spokesman, said Hague should have
declared his stay on Ashcroft's yacht.
"Hague is covering up Lord Ashcroft's lavish hospitality by not
declaring he's stayed on his yacht for the price of a hotel room. It's
like Hague claiming that he does not have to declare his flights on a
private jet because he has handed over the fare of a Ryanair ticket."
Hague's three-day Cuban visit began on 15 March 2009 when he flew with
Ashcroft into Havana, courtesy of a private jet from Flying Lion Ltd, a
company controlled by the Belize-based billionaire. Hague has flown with
the company on at least 10 previous occasions.
The relationship between the two men is very close, according to Tory
insiders. Ashcroft was the Conservative party's main financial backer
during Hague's four years as leader from 1997 to 2001, and he was
nominated by Hague for a peerage. He now runs Conservative party
strategy in marginal seats, and sits in on meetings in his capacity as
the party's deputy chairman.
While in Havana, they met Panama's then foreign minister, Samuel Lewis
Navarro. According to Panamanian news reports from three years ago,
Ashcroft and Navarro were co-directors of Panama Holdings Subsidiary
Inc. Together, the group met with Cuba's foreign minister Bruno
Rodríguez Parrilla for a three-hour lunch in the capital. That evening,
Hague and Ashcroft retired to one of Ashcroft's two "mega-yachts".
The British embassy in Havana was surprised to receive a telephone call
from Hague in which he announced he was in the country and suggested a
meeting with the ambassador, Dianna Melrose.
"It was unusual, to say the least. We get very few visiting dignitaries
here because of Foreign Office rules," said one embassy official. "They
came over for a meeting and talked openly about their meetings with
Cuban government officials. Then they went back to Ashcroft's yacht."
Hague has visited the region before, courtesy of Ashcroft's company. He
stayed in accommodation provided by Navarro on a visit to Panama in
2007. It was then that Hague also visited Belize, the tax haven where
Ashcroft's business has been based for nearly 30 years, as well as the
Turks and Caicos Islands, where Ashcroft's bank has interests.
Ashcroft has repeatedly refused to clarify his tax status in Britain.
His company, Bearwood Corporate Services, is at the centre of an
Electoral Commission investigation into whether millions of pounds given
to the Tories were in breach of electoral law, following allegations
that the company was not "carrying on business" in Britain.
According to Hague's spokesman, he paid Ashcroft for his two-night stay
in his yacht at a rate equivalent to two nights' stay in a top hotel,
but declined to say how much he had paid or his method of payment. In
his entry to the register of members' interests, Hague declared the
flights from Flying Lion, but added: "I covered the cost of my
One former parliamentary official last night said Hague's decision not
to actually register his stay on the yacht was outside the spirit of the
rules. Alistair Graham, the former chair of the Committee on Standards
in Public Life, said: "The key point is whether he entered an obligation
when he stayed on the yacht. I think his decision not to mention it is
outside the spirit of the rules," he said.
Hague's spokesman last night defended his decision to hold talks with a
Cuban minister with Ashcroft. "We are not confined as the opposition by
such a protocol and actual EU governments vary greatly in how they
interpret it. The purpose of Mr Hague's visit to Cuba was to engage with
Cuba's leaders and assess the effectiveness of EU policy towards Cuba.
His view is that the communist regime in Havana may find a degree of
opening up to their country by Europe and the USA a greater challenge
than the sanctions imposed in recent times."
A spokesman for Ashcroft declined to comment on his relationship with
Hague or Navarro but said that the peer had no investments in Cuba, and
had no plans to invest in Cuba in the future.
William Hague's Cuba trip raises new questions on Lord Ashcroft's Tory
role | Politics | The Observer (31 January 2010)